Thursday, December 29, 2016

Who Rules the Schools ?

The Constitution of the United States makes no mention or reference to the education of America’s children. It is a surprising fact. However the Tenth Amendment does state that any issues that are not covered by the Constitution become the purview of the individual states (states rights). Thus there are 50 state departments of education, 50 sets of requirements for teacher certifications and 50 sets (at least) of state approved curricula. The debate about Common Core has run head on to the last statement.  In looking at the nomination of Betsy DeVos as the new US Secretary of Education, it seems clear that the federal government does want to get more involved with the education of America’s children. This nomination seems even more puzzling when you consider the fact that the President-elect will be looking for a US Supreme Court Justice to succeed the late Antonin Scalia. Scalia was a “Strict Constructionist” and believed in a literal interpretation of the Constitution rather than viewing the Constitution as a living document that needs to change with the times. Can we have it both ways? I don’t think so. If we want less federal government intrusion in our lives (and the lives of our school age children), then we need to commit to the right of the individual states to determine the direction of their public schools. That means working together with parents, teachers and community leaders to develop the best strategies that will ensure our children’s success in school.

Best wishes for a Happy New Year


C.2016 J. Margolis

No comments:

Post a Comment